I have just finished reading The True Story of Pocahontas so that I can compare it to the Disney film and to prepare for our upcoming inquiry essay. I learned quite a bit from the book, however, there were a few things that I didn't like about it. First of all, the book was very short (only 95 pages), and it wasn't written very well. It was also extremely repetitive; the author would make the same point several times on one page and just repeat the same information, which could make the book very dry. Also, the information presented in the book came from Native American oral history that had been passed down through the generations. The author never acknowledged the possibility that the story could have lost some accuracy through that time. Also, the book was very biased. The authors described the story completely from the Native American's perspective and had nothing positive to say about the English colonists.
Nonetheless, assuming that the information presented was correct, the book did present some interesting information. For instance, Pocahontas was only 10 years old when John Smith came to the colony, and any unsupervised interaction between them was extremely limited, if even existent, during John Smith's stay in the colonies. This would have made it extremely unlikely that Pocahontas ever saved John Smith's life, let alone that they fell in love as the Disney movie suggests.
You're a good reviewer! This is a very thorough analysis that definitely convinced me I don't need to bother with this book. I learned from a middle school history class the truth about Pocahontas as well.
ReplyDeleteThe very title makes the book sound dry. If there's a TRUE story of Pocahontas, and everyone knows the FALSE one, then odds are that unless there's some crazy conspiracy cover-up, the FALSE story is more exciting and makes for a better Disney movie anyway.
ReplyDelete