I am still having trouble brainstorming ideas for our tragedy project. I'm currently leading towards photography, but I'm not entirely sure this is the best direction to go in. I need to work on this over this weekend. I also need to work on reading my independent reading book. Unlike Pride and Prejudice I'm having a really hard time getting into Emma. Hopefully this will pick up as I keep reading.
Friday, October 29, 2010
Friday, October 22, 2010
Tragedy? Perhaps not.
While reading Oedipus the King, one of the topics we discussed throughout was whether or not this was a true tragedy, as Aristotle claimed it to be. However, once I was done reading the play, I did not really find the play truly tragic. Part of what is supposed to define a tragedy as such, according to the Greeks, was a feeling of raw emotion, usually one that is very sad, that the audience experienced while watching it, and I didn't really get that from Oedipus the King. Ironically, I found it more comedic than tragic.
I have heard before that one way to make something truly comedic is absurdity. I found Oedipus the King very absurd. Of all the people Oedipus could have met walking from the Oracale, how likely is it that one of the people he should meet is his biological father? Or that he should travel to Thebes, of all places, and then of all the women he could have married, how likely is it that he should marry his mother. The likelihood of all these things happening is very unlikely, which makes it so absurd, in addition to being rather funny. Well, except for the fact that he and his mother had children together; that's more disturbing than humorous.
Overall, I liked reading Oedipus the King, I just didn't find it very tragic.
I have heard before that one way to make something truly comedic is absurdity. I found Oedipus the King very absurd. Of all the people Oedipus could have met walking from the Oracale, how likely is it that one of the people he should meet is his biological father? Or that he should travel to Thebes, of all places, and then of all the women he could have married, how likely is it that he should marry his mother. The likelihood of all these things happening is very unlikely, which makes it so absurd, in addition to being rather funny. Well, except for the fact that he and his mother had children together; that's more disturbing than humorous.
Overall, I liked reading Oedipus the King, I just didn't find it very tragic.
Friday, October 15, 2010
What makes a tragedy?
We have begun studying tragedy in class; we are reading the play Oedipus Rex, which, according to Aristotle, is the perfect tragedy. We are also watching clips of movies in class that have very tragic scenes.
I started talking to my mom about tragic movies last night; she claimed that one of the saddest scenes from a movie that she had watched was when the Wicked Witch of the West took Toto away from Dorothy in the movie the Wizard of Oz. I disagreed. I didn't think it was really that tragic; it was sad, yes, but in the end everything turns out okay, and you know that. But it made me really start thinking, what seperates sad movies and tragic movies? This of course could also apply to books, plays, and such. I think what makes a movie scene truly tragic, and depressing above all else, is the knowledge that there is no way to completely fix a situation. For example, the movie Mrs. Miniver I believe has a truly tragic ending. The movie takes place during WWII, and there is a scene at the end of the movie where a young girl, who had just gotten married two weeks before, dies after being shot while sitting in her car during an air raid; she dies not long after. I think that this scene is truly tragic because there is no way to truly fix this situation; the girl is always going to be dead after that, and her family will always suffer because of it.
I started talking to my mom about tragic movies last night; she claimed that one of the saddest scenes from a movie that she had watched was when the Wicked Witch of the West took Toto away from Dorothy in the movie the Wizard of Oz. I disagreed. I didn't think it was really that tragic; it was sad, yes, but in the end everything turns out okay, and you know that. But it made me really start thinking, what seperates sad movies and tragic movies? This of course could also apply to books, plays, and such. I think what makes a movie scene truly tragic, and depressing above all else, is the knowledge that there is no way to completely fix a situation. For example, the movie Mrs. Miniver I believe has a truly tragic ending. The movie takes place during WWII, and there is a scene at the end of the movie where a young girl, who had just gotten married two weeks before, dies after being shot while sitting in her car during an air raid; she dies not long after. I think that this scene is truly tragic because there is no way to truly fix this situation; the girl is always going to be dead after that, and her family will always suffer because of it.
Wednesday, October 6, 2010
Pride and Prejudice
I have just finished reading Pride and Prejudice, and I have to say that I absolutely loved it. I have meant to read it for years, but I always put it off because I figured it was going to be too hard. I was completely mistaken; although it wasn't easy, it was by no means beyond my reach.
As part of our project, I am trying to find out exactly what makes Jane Austen's books so appealing, despite the fact that her books were written in the 1800s. After reading her book, I decided that there are two main qualities that make Pride and Prejudice such an appealing read. First, it has relateable qualities, despite how long ago it was written. For example, just as a woman today wouldn't likely marry someone that they didn't love, Elizabeth couldn't bring herself to marry Mr. Collins because she did not love him. Secondly, Pride and Prejudice has very romantic qualities. For example, the reason that Mr. Darcy begins to fall in love with Elizabeth is because she has "very fine eyes" and the "livelyness of her mind". I can think of very few women who wouldn't want a man to fall in love with them for those reasons.
I still have some thinking to do to figure out what else makes this such an appealing read; I need to work on this before our essay on Tuesday.
As part of our project, I am trying to find out exactly what makes Jane Austen's books so appealing, despite the fact that her books were written in the 1800s. After reading her book, I decided that there are two main qualities that make Pride and Prejudice such an appealing read. First, it has relateable qualities, despite how long ago it was written. For example, just as a woman today wouldn't likely marry someone that they didn't love, Elizabeth couldn't bring herself to marry Mr. Collins because she did not love him. Secondly, Pride and Prejudice has very romantic qualities. For example, the reason that Mr. Darcy begins to fall in love with Elizabeth is because she has "very fine eyes" and the "livelyness of her mind". I can think of very few women who wouldn't want a man to fall in love with them for those reasons.
I still have some thinking to do to figure out what else makes this such an appealing read; I need to work on this before our essay on Tuesday.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)